What is a good process to write historical fiction?

Post date: 2020-08-09 06:57:39
Views: 155
How would you even begin to write a novel set in the Roman Republic?

I absolutely adore I, Claudius and its sequel. I love historical novels like Pillars of the Earth, Augustus by John Williams, Sarum and London by Edward Rutherford, and other novels that transport you to a different time and place -- creating characters you can connect with, in a world you've never known, amidst stunning historical events.

I'd love to try to write one of these. There's an aristocratic woman from the Roman Republic whom I find fascinating and who possibly played a role in major events at that time. I have the idea of a novel that follows her as well as an enslaved young woman in her household, in the midst of these events. I've purchased and read a couple books about women and/or slaves in ancient Rome, but they are both highly academic and highly limiting. Very basic questions that I have seem difficult to get an answer on -- such as "What would this character do in the morning? Where and how would they be interacting with other people in their life? Would this character be able to go out into the street alone? How much agency would this character realistically have? What would the historical events that are happening look like on a day-to-day level?" And while I love novels like I, Claudius and Augustus, their focus on upper-class male characters feels rather distant from what I'm working on. Many other historical novels about the Roman Republic appear to be focused on various wars of the time, whereas I'm much more interested in day-to-day life.

I've started writing, and I find what I've written terrible. The feeling that the best historical novels have, of sweeping you into a world, of having a glimpse of all the details of regular life and of characters that feel both timeless and of their time, is totally absent. I am utterly stuck on plot - while I have a loose outline of the big picture of the novel, the day-to-day of these characters seems impossible to grasp for me. If anything, the outline seems to be hurting me, as it's tying my writing too close to the few big-picture historical events that happened, and not allowing life to breathe.

I'm now thoroughly stuck, and I've put the work down. I'm frustrated. To be fair, this is not an easy project I've embarked on, and just because I like reading this type of novel doesn't mean I am the one to write one. Though I have finished other large creative projects, I've never actually written a complete novel - just started a couple and put them down. And because I've chosen two subjects for whom there is very little extant historical information, this may be uniquely hard. But I truly do want to give this a shot. I should probably re-read I, Claudius. I should probably read other novels set in the Roman Republic, even if most of them seem to be about Great Men or Big Wars. I should possibly choose one of my two lead characters and focus on her.

But right now this is feeling overwhelming. Any advice?
Number of Comments
Please click Here to read the full story.
 
Other Top and Latest Questions:
Abercrombie shares soar 20% on Hollister growth, strong earnings beat
Applying to jobs from Thanksgiving to New Year's isn't pointless, experts say: 'You actually have more opportunity to stand out'
Dick's Sporting Goods to shutter some Foot Locker stores to protect profits
Private payroll losses accelerated in the past four weeks, ADP reports
Core wholesale prices rose less than expected in September; retail sales gain
Some of the big risks for the market in 2026, according to JPMorgan
Bessent says there's a 'very good chance' Trump names new Fed chair before Christmas
CNBC's Official NHL Team Valuations 2025: Here's how the 32 franchises stack up
Consumer confidence hits lowest point since April as job worries grow
Ukraine reportedly agrees to U.S.-brokered peace proposal