U4GM Guide to MLB The Show 26 Underrated Cards
Posted by Andrew123fh
from the Agriculture category at
08 Jul 2026 03:16:38 am.
Share this page: 
Kazuma Okamoto still feels like a cheat code
Kazuma Okamoto from the World Baseball Classic set is one of those cards that sneaks into a lineup and then refuses to leave. At 92 overall, he has the kind of power you notice fast. The 90 power plays exactly how you would want it to, and his swing has that clean, easy rhythm that lets you stay on time without forcing anything. A lot of players will tell you the same thing after a few games: he just squares up pitches in a way that feels natural. Even at Parallel 5, he can hang with much bigger names because his bat keeps the pressure on every at-bat.
Why Anthony Santander keeps showing up in good lineups
Anthony Santander is a different kind of pick. On the surface, the contact looks rough, and 61 contact is not going to impress anybody at first glance. But the 87 power changes the whole conversation. He is one of those live series bats that seems to do more than the card suggests, especially if you are already decent at making solid contact. You do not need to sell the farm for him either, which matters a lot when you are trying to build a competitive team without burning through your stash too fast.
| Kazuma Okamoto | 92 | Strong enough | 90 | Easy swing, big damage |
| Anthony Santander | Live Series | 61 | 87 | Outperforms the ratings |
| Eddie Rosario | 89 | 86 | 82 | Balanced bat, useful defense |
Eddie Rosario from the World Baseball Classic Series may be the best surprise in the bunch. The 89 overall card does not scream elite at first, but once you start using him, that changes pretty quickly. With 86 contact and 82 power, he gives you a little of everything. He can hit for average, he can drive the ball, and he does not feel empty anywhere in the box. The 55 speed helps too. It is not game-breaking, sure, but it is enough to make him useful in left field and save you from feeling stuck on the bases.
What to look for when you want better results
If you are trying to build a lineup that actually works, start with feel, not hype. Some cards just fit better because of their swing, stance, or the way they track pitches. Here are a few things smart players usually check first:
- Does the swing feel quick without being rushed?
- Can the player still punish mistakes when contact is not perfect?
- Does the card offer enough defense or speed to stay on the field?
- Is the price or cost of acquisition reasonable for what you get?
0 Comments